7 Comments

I like that so far Mary Poppins is winning 100-0. Nine is getting exactly as many votes as it deserves. I love the stage version, and if you had told me in 2003 there would be movie of it and the best part would be Fergie, I never would have believed you.

Expand full comment

I despise Mary Poppins and will vote for anything over it. Even Nine, apparently.

Expand full comment

I loathe Mary Poppins (there was something I truly could not stand about poorly-executed accents when I was a little kid), but even the potential anti-vote isn't enough to give Nine a bump up. You made me vote for MP, Josh! I thought I'd be safe with musicals.

Expand full comment

I can't fathom anyone hating Mary Poppins, but I REALLY can't fathom anyone thinking that Nine is better than MP. At the very least, Mary Poppins is competently directed and features a lead actor who can actually sing and put over musical numbers.

Expand full comment

“Eye-rollingly silly”?!? That’s some real John Lithgow in Footloose energy there.

Expand full comment

Confessional time: I LOVE the film Nine 👀🫥🫣

Expand full comment

That day is today friends. Prince does nothing for me.

Expand full comment