7 Comments

I know I'll lose this one, but... I've never been a Mary Poppins fan. It just doesn't resonate for me. Enchanted, though, I can watch over and over, and so much of that is due to Amy Adams's charm in that role.

Expand full comment

Amy Adams in Enchanted doesn't happen without Julie Andrews in Mary Poppins. I might argue that this should have been the final, but it's still our beloved nanny here.

Expand full comment

Very very tough but...it’s Andrew’s

Expand full comment

I love Amy Adams in Enchanted so much, however, I am a Julie Andrews/Mary Poppins girl first and foremost so I didn't really have the hardest time voting lol

Expand full comment

Fun to read this just minutes after listening to Bill Simmons on The Rewatchables podcast go on an extended rant about how bad Adams is in Catch Me If You Can!! (I’m on your side.)

Expand full comment

Bill Simmons' takes on movies are...uh...Not Great, Bob. (IMO)

Expand full comment

I find him always interesting to listen to, and often wildly off track. His Amy Adams take was . . . not shared by the other hosts.

Expand full comment